N8240 Hwy E, Watertown WI 53094
Like us on Facebook Donny's Girl, LLC Supper Club

Donny's Girl mouthwatering prime rib dinner

Our Menu

Beloved by generations of locals and out-of-towners alike, there is no better place to enjoy classic supper club cuisine and spirits than Donny's Girl. As proud owners, Lorn and I are pleased to offer same service and quality my parents worked so hard to achieve for 22 years.

Come and join us for dinner!

Effective Febraury 1, 2018

"Donny’s Girl is a superior Supper Club with a varied menu and outstanding food including an unsurpassed salad bar and congenial service all at reasonable prices and in an exceptionally fun- friendly atmosphere. A must dining experience.”
—John and Nancy Raasch, Pewaukee


Potato Skins

Fried skins loaded with cheese & served with a side of sour cream

Haystack Onion Rings

Our irresistibly thin sliced onions fried and piled high
full order: $4.95
half order: $3.50

Beer Battered Mushrooms

Fresh button mushrooms fried in a homemade beer batter

Mozzarella Sticks

Bite size, stuffed full of mozzarella served with our homemade marinara

Loaded Nachos

Our homemade corn tortilla chips served with seasoned beef, cheese sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, sliced black olives, with salsa and sour cream on the side, fresh pico de gallo and guacamole
substitute chicken $10.95

Fried Cheese Curds

Fresh Wisconsin Cheese Curds breaded & deep fried


Melted cheese sandwiched between grilled corn tortillas, with sour cream, fresh pico de gallo and guacamole
with beef or chicken: $9.95

Shrimp Cocktail

5 Chilled jumbo shrimp served with cocktail sauce

back to top
Daily Features



A German favorite, Donny’s recipe sweet & sour sliced beef with gingersnap gravy.
Served with red cabbage & mashed potatoes


Tenderloin Tips & Noodles

In a burgundy gravy with mushrooms & onions served on a bed of egg noodles

Spaghetti & Meatballs

A bed of spaghetti noodles topped with our homemade marinara and meatballs,
served with garlic toast


Corned Beef & Cabbage

Traditionally thin sliced corned beef served with cabbage,
boiled red potatoes and vegetables


Family Style Fish & Chicken


Baked Cod








All of the above served with french fries, coleslaw, potato salad,
baked beans, and rye bread

Not a fish fan?

No problem. Click here for additional entrees for a most flavorful Friday!

Saturday and Sunday

BBQ Ribs

Our tender pork ribs smothered in barbecue sauce
Half Rack: $15.95
Full Rack: $20.95

Available Saturday with other "chef's choice" features

Available on Sunday, Monday and Thursday

Lamb Shank

Tender roasted shank served in a mushroom gravy with a side of mint jelly

4 Piece Fried Cod

12 oz. serving of our lightly breaded & deep fried cod, served with tartar sauce

Bistro Beef Medallions

Bistro beef broiled your way and topped with housemade bourbon bacon au jus

back to top

Served with fries or cup of soup
Add salad bar: $3.00

Sirloin Burger

1/2 lb. Hand pattied sirloin burger grilled to perfection


1/2 lb. Hand pattied burger grilled to perfection topped with choice of cheese

Taco Burger

Seasoned sirloin patty made with black olives & topped
with shredded cheddar, lettuce, tomato and red onion.
Served with salsa on the side

Mort Sandwich

Grilled cheese with choice of cheese, bacon and sliced tomato

Open Face Prime Rib Sandwich

Thin sliced prime rib on toasted bread, smothered with mushrooms & onions,
served with a side of horseradish and au jus
add cheese: $.50

Lorn Special

Golden fried chicken breast topped with mozzarella cheese,
bacon & tomato, served with a side of ranch

Fish Sandwich

Cod deep fried golden brown topped with lettuce,
tomato, choice of cheese and a side of tartar

back to top

Add cup of soup $1.75

Black and Bleu

Tossed greens topped with cajun seasoned sirloin, red onion & tomatoes,
served with bleu cheese dressing
Substitute salmon: $14.95

Balsamic Chicken Salad

Crisp romaine tossed with sundried tomatoes, red onion, sliced black & green olives
and balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
Topped with grilled chicken breast strips & feta cheese

Citrus Chicken

Tossed greens topped with a grilled chicken breast, mandarin oranges,
almonds and citrus vinagrette

Tortilla Strip Taco Salad

Crisp iceberg lettuce topped with seasoned beef, tomato, shredded cheddar,
red onion & black olives beside fresh fried tortilla strips.
Salsa ranch dressing served on the side

back to top
Lighter Fare

Loaded Baked Potato

Oven baked potato topped with bacon, shredded cheddar and onion,
served with sour cream & salsa on the side.
With a side salad: $5.95
With salad bar: $8.25

Baked French Onion Soup

A crock of our French onion soup topped with a slice of garlic toast,
smothered in mozzarella cheese

Popcorn Shrimp

Deep fried golden brown served with cocktail sauce and choice of potato
Add salad bar: $3.00

Salad Bar

Salad Bar only with Soup of the Day: $7.50
Salad Bar only with Baked French Onion soup: $10

back to top

Lobster Dinner

Succulent 9 oz. lobster tail served with clarified butter
(1) $29.95
(2) $47.95

Baked Cod

12 oz. loin baked to perfection served with clarified butter
ALA OSCAR: topped with steamed asparagus and imitation crabmeat,
smothered in hollandaise


6 jumbo shrimp cooked your way served with clarified butter or cocktail sauce, french fried or sautéed

Walleye Pike

Walleye filet fried golden brown or broiled almandine served with clarified butter


Salmon filet baked and served with dill butter
Orange Glazed: lightly cajun seasoned salmon filet baked, then pan fried with orange marmalade glaze


6 large scallops cooked your way served with clarified butter or tartar sauce, french fried or sautéed

Shrimp (4) & Scallops (4)

Shrimp & scallops combination cooked to your preference

Four Stuffed Shrimp

4 jumbo shrimp stuffed with Monterey Jack cheese and crab meat fried golden brown

back to top

Tenderloin, 6 oz. & Shrimp or Scallops (3)


Tenderloin, 6 oz. & 2 Stuffed Shrimp


Tenderloin, 6 oz. & Lobster Tail


Prime Rib, 8 oz. & Shrimp or Scallops (3)


Prime Rib, 8 oz. & Lobster Tail


back to top
Ala Carte

Sautéed Vegetables


Cup of Soup


Bowl of Soup


back to top

Prime Rib

A thick cut of our slow roasted USDA choice prime rib, served with au jus
8 oz: 17.95
16 oz: $22.95


6 oz. petite USDA choice tenderloin broiled your way, served with au jus


8 oz. USDA choice tenderloin broiled your way, served with au jus

New York Strip

12 oz. king of steaks broiled to order

Black & Bleu: Cajun seasoned & topped with melted bleu cheese


16 oz. cut mouthwatering and broiled to order

Pork Chops

2 chops broiled or fried to a golden brown served with applesauce

Broiled Chicken Breast

8 oz. broiled chicken breast served with cranberry sauce
ALA OSCAR: topped with steamed asparagus and imitation crabmeat,
smothered in hollandaise
SMOTHERED: topped with sautéed mushrooms & onions
and covered with melted mozzarella cheese

Roast Duck

Honey kissed, roasted 1/2 duck served with cherry wine sauce

Bistro Beef Medallions for Two

Bistro beef broiled your way and topped with housemade
bourbon bacon au jus

Sautéed Chicken Livers

Pan sautéed, with sizzling bacon, onions & mushrooms

(Not available on Fridays)

French Fried Half Chicken

4 pc. deep fried golden brown served with a side of cranberry sauce
All white meat, add $1.50

(Not available on Fridays)

Lamb Chops

Broiled to order and served with mint jelly


10 oz. cut of juicy hamsteak served with applesauce & grilled pineapple

For meals above add mushrooms or onions $2.00, add both for $3.95

All dinners served with choice of potato, salad bar, soup of the day and bread
Baked French onion: add $1.50

back to top
Kid's Choice Menu

Ages 12 & Under
$5.50 +tax

Donny's Girl Kid's Choice Menu

Main Dish (choose 1)

Grilled Cheese • 2-Piece Fish Plate
Chicken Strips • Spaghetti & Meatballs
Macaroni & Cheese • Pair of Mini-Burgers
Salad Bar with Cup of Soup (or side)

Side (choose 1)

French Fries • Cottage Cheese
Potato Salad • Apple Sauce
Mandarin Oranges • Cole Slaw

Beverage (choose 1)

2% Milk • Chocolate Milk
Apple Juice • Lemonade
Pepsi • Sierra Mist • Mountain Dew
Kiddy Cocktail

Each Kid's Choice Meal includes side as listed and one beverage (sorry, no free refills). Ages 12 & under only. Kid's Choice Meals may not be shared or split. Add Salad Bar: $2.00. Salad Bar not available on Fridays.

back to top

Ask about our seasonal dessert specials!

Celebration Cake & Ice Cream

For any occasion, a decorated cupcake with a scoop of ice cream and candle

New York Cheesecake

A classic favorite, plain or topped with strawberries, cherries or chocolate and whipped cream


Chocolate, strawberry, or caramel, topped with whipped cream

Schaum Torte

Traditional recipe, light & airy, topped with strawberries

Chocolate Angel Pie

Rich and fluffy chocolate filling on a graham cracker crust

back to top


Call Us for Reservations 920-262-1919


  • Mon: 5 - 9 pm
  • Tue: Closed
  • Wed: Closed
  • Thu: 5 - 9 pm
  • Fri: 4 - 10 pm
  • Sat: 5 - 9:30 pm
  • Sun: 4 - 9 pm


Our bar opens 30 minutes
prior to dining hours.