N8240 Hwy E, Watertown WI 53094
Like us on Facebook Donny's Girl, LLC Supper Club

Donny's Girl mouthwatering prime rib dinner

Our Menu

Beloved by generations of locals and out-of-towners alike, there is no better place to enjoy classic supper club cuisine and spirits than Donny's Girl. As proud owners, Lorn and I are pleased to offer same service and quality my parents worked so hard to achieve for 22 years.

Come and join us for dinner!

Effective February 2020

"Donny’s Girl is a superior Supper Club with a varied menu and outstanding food including an unsurpassed salad bar and congenial service all at reasonable prices and in an exceptionally fun- friendly atmosphere. A must dining experience.”
—John and Nancy Raasch, Pewaukee


Haystack Onion Rings

Our irresistibly thin sliced onions fried and piled high
Half order $4.50
Full order: $5.95

Stuffed Mushrooms

Golden panko fried stuffed mushroom caps

Deep Fried Brussels Sprouts

Fresh brussels sprouts fried and served with house-made marinade

Cheese Curds

Kraemer fresh cheese curds with house-made batter, fried golden brown

Mozzarella Sticks

Crispy fried mozzarella sticks served with marinara sauce

Shrimp Cocktail

5 Chilled jumbo shrimp served with cocktail sauce

Sautéed Chicken Livers

Pan sautéed with bacon, onions, mushrooms and pan sauce

Baked French Onion

A crock of our French onion soup topped with garlic toast and Mozzarella cheese

back to top
Nightly Specials



A German favorite, Donny’s recipe sweet & sour sliced beef with gingersnap gravy.
Served with red cabbage and mashed potatoes


Tenderloin Tips & Noodles

In a burgundy gravy with mushrooms & onions served on a bed of egg noodles


House recipe lasagna loaded with cheese & served with Texas toast

Spaghetti & Meatballs

Spaghetti noodles topped with house-made marinara and meatballs, served with Texas toast


“Chef’s Choice”

Please ask your server for details



Family Style Fish & Chicken

Lightly breaded cod filets & house seasoned chicken, fried golden brown served family style (all you care to eat in house)

Baked Cod








Friday specials served with french fries, coleslaw, potato salad,
baked beans, and rye bread.

Not a fish fan?

No problem. Click here for additional entrees for a most flavorful Friday!

Saturday and Sunday

BBQ Ribs

Tender pork ribs smothered in barbeque sauce
Half Rack: $16.95
Full Rack: $21.95

Available Saturday with other "chef's choice" features

Available on Sunday, Monday and Thursday

Lamb Shank

Tender roasted shank served in a mushroom gravy with a side of mint jelly

4 Piece Fried Cod

12 oz. serving of our lightly breaded and fried cod, served with tartar sauce

All Nightly Specials available in addition to "Chef's Choice" offerings!

back to top

Served with fries or cup of soup
Add salad bar: $3.00
Add Baked French Onion:$3.00

Burger or Cheeseburger

1/2 lb. Hand-pattied burger grilled to order. Cheese: American, Cheddar or Mozzerlla.

Mort Sandwich

Grilled cheddar cheese with bacon and sliced tomato

Lorn Special

Chicken breast fried golden with mozzarella, bacon, tomato and ranch dressing

Fish Sandwich

2 pieces of golden fried cod with lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese and tartar sauce

back to top
Lighter Fare

Popcorn Shrimp

Bite size shrimp fried golden brown served with starch choice and cocktail sauce

Loaded Baked Potato

Oven baked potato with bacon, shredded cheddar and onion served with sour cream;

With a side salad: $6.95
With salad bar: $9.95

5 oz. Petite Filet

*USDA choice tenderloin broiled to order with starch choice & salad or soup

Salad Bar (not available Friday)

Salad bar only as meal with cup of soup of the day
With Baked French Onion: $11.95

Create your own Entrée Salad (not available Friday)

Build your own from salad bar & top it with a choice of protein.
*5 oz. Tenderloin: $11.95
Salmon Filet: $14.95
Broiled Chicken Breast: $10.95

back to top

Lobster Dinner

Succulent 9 oz. lobster tail served with melted butter
(1) $29.95
(2) $47.95

Baked Cod

12 oz. loin baked to perfection served with clarified butter
Baked Cod ala Oscar: with asparagus, imitation crabmeat and hollandaise sauce

Orange Glazed Salmon

Lightly Cajun-seasoned salmon filet with orange marmalade glaze


6 jumbo scallops sautéed or lightly breaded & fried with melted butter or tartar sauce


6 jumbo shrimp sautéed or lightly breaded and fried with melted butter or cocktail sauce

Four Stuffed Shrimp

Shrimp, Monterey Jack cheese & imitation crab meat inside a light breading fried golden brown

Walleye Pike

Walleye filet broiled almandine or lightly breaded & fried with melted butter or tartar sauce

back to top

Prime Rib, 8 oz. or Filet, 8 oz. with

3 Shrimp, 3 Scallops or 2 Stuffed Shrimp: $26.95

Prime Rib, 8 oz or Filet, 8 oz. with

1 Lobster Tail: $38.95

back to top

Prime Rib

*A thick cut of our slow roasted USDA choice prime rib;
8 oz: 17.95
16 oz: $22.95


8 oz.* USDA choice tenderloin broiled your way, served with au jus

Grilled Ribeye

14 oz. *USDA house cut choice ribeye broiled to order

New York Strip

12 oz. *King of steaks broiled to order


16 oz. *Cut mouthwatering and broiled to order

Roast Duck

Honey kissed, roasted 1/2 duck served with cherry wine sauce

Chicken Breast

Pan Fried juicy chicken breast: $13.95
Smothered with sautéed mushrooms & onions, covered with melted mozzarella: $16.95

French Fried Half Chicken

4-piece, house-seasoned and fried chicken with a side of cranberry sauce

Veal Marsala

Tender veal cutlets pan fried with a mushroom wine reduction

All dinners served with choice of potato, salad bar, soup of the day and bread.
Baked French onion: add $3.00

back to top
Kid's Choice Menu

Ages 12 & Under
$6.00 +tax

Donny's Girl Kid's Choice Menu

Main Dish (choose 1)

Grilled Cheese • 2-Piece Fish Plate
Chicken Strips • French Bread Pizza
Macaroni & Cheese • Salad Bar with side
Hamburger or Cheeseburger

Side (choose 1)

French Fries • Cottage Cheese
Mandarin Oranges • Applesauce

Beverage (choose 1)

2% Milk • Chocolate Milk
Apple Juice • Lemonade
Pepsi • Sierra Mist • Mountain Dew • Root Beer
Kiddy Cocktail

Each Kid's Choice Meal includes side as listed and one beverage (sorry, no free refills). Ages 12 & under only. Kid's Choice Meals may not be shared or split. Add Salad Bar: $2.00. Salad Bar not available on Fridays.

back to top

Schaum Torte<

Traditional recipe served with vanilla ice cream & topped with strawberries
Pre-order a 9x13 pan for events, celebrations or anytime to take home!

New York Cheesecake

A classic favorite, plain or with choice of topping

Turtle Cheesecake

Caramel swirled cheesecake with chocolate and nut toppings

Chocolate Angel Pie

Rich and fluffy chocolate mousse filling on graham cracker crust


Vanilla ice cream with choice of chocolate, strawberry or caramel topping

back to top

An 18% gratuity may be added to parties of 8 or more, separate checks or coupons. We are not responsible for steaks ordered well done. Quantities are not guaranteed, sorry no price substitutions. No sharing/splitting meals.*Whether dining out or preparing food at home, consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions. Items & prices are subject to change. All Prices subject to Wisconsin sales tax.



Call Us for Reservations 920-262-1919


  • Sun: 4 - 9 p.m.
  • Mon: 4:30 - 9 p.m.
  • Tue: Closed
  • Wed: Closed
  • Thu: 4:30 - 9 p.m.
  • Fri: 4 - 9 p.m.
  • Sat: 4:30 - 9 p.m.


Our bar opens 30 minutes
prior to dining hours.